For: 0 | Against: 5 | Abstain: 1
+against — @bixbite
+abstain — @travsap
+against — @brettdrawsstuff
+against — @joaoborges
+against — @moctezuma3ro
+against +1 krel — @datadanne.eth
The nouniverse has voted through $NOGS ⌐◨-◨
FOR: 4 AGAINST: 5
31680 $NOGS have been shared among the participants.
Very firmly against this prop in its current form. While I love the idea of a nounish TCG, any game we fund should exemplify not just nouns as an IP, but nounish values. I'm not seeing anything of the sort in this prop.
I have more specific feedback, but it got a bit lengthy- happy to connect and share the individual issues where I won't text wall the voting feed.
Nouncil has spoken.
We discuss all Nouns proposals every week in our Discord https://discord.gg/fdjJpMeV6K. The calls are public and all are welcome!
You can find a link to previous call recordings in our Discord "links" channel.
Nouncil has voted Against this proposal, with 3 votes for, 28 against, and 8 abstentions. Thanks for playing Nouns, see comments below:
FOR - 3 VOTES
AGAINST - 28 VOTES
sqx.pcc | "a few things turn me no. but the 1 year license in a CC0 world sealed the no."
ABSTAINS - 8 VOTES
Very firmly against this prop in its current form. While I love the idea of a nounish TCG, any game we fund should exemplify not just nouns as an IP, but nounish values. I'm not seeing anything of the sort in this prop.
I have more specific feedback, but it got a bit lengthy- happy to connect and share the individual issues where I won't text wall the voting feed.
It's actually quite a bit of funding, but I haven't thought to say yes to this proposal yet. It needs some revisions and of course the original sector of this card will be
I’m abstaining on this one, but there’s definitely potential here. As a board game fan myself (though too busy for it these days, unfortunately), I love the concept of bringing Nounish mythology into a physical trading card game. That said, I think the proposal could use a bit more polish. Seeing some actual card designs would really help get people excited, and there needs to be a clearer picture of how this will benefit Nouns beyond just Devcon. The licensing also needs to be more in line with Nouns’ CC0 ethos to avoid any friction.
would wish for the team to aim higher and create something more unique, bespoke. Overall ⌐◨-◨ integration doesn't make bold impression to me and too interchangeable.
⌐◨-◨
Would like to this re-proposed with all of the feedback taken into account- cc0 clarification, etc..
https://www.lilnouns.wtf/vote/nounsdao/636/votes
FOR 0 VOTES
AGAINST 151 VOTES
ABSTAIN 101 VOTES
Nouncil has spoken.
We discuss all Nouns proposals every week in our Discord https://discord.gg/fdjJpMeV6K. The calls are public and all are welcome!
You can find a link to previous call recordings in our Discord "links" channel.
Nouncil has voted Against this proposal, with 3 votes for, 28 against, and 8 abstentions. Thanks for playing Nouns, see comments below:
FOR - 3 VOTES
AGAINST - 28 VOTES
sqx.pcc | "a few things turn me no. but the 1 year license in a CC0 world sealed the no."
ABSTAINS - 8 VOTES
seems like a small ask for a nice product built by a very passionate individual. it's an easy yes from me.
the majority of the prop is for design but we couldnt get mock ups of the cards? I LOVE TCGs and still collect them myself, recently buying a manga Luffy card but this doesnt make me excited.
would wish for the team to aim higher and create something more unique, bespoke. Overall ⌐◨-◨ integration doesn't make bold impression to me and too interchangeable.
Would love to see the sketches, how youre choosing which art to use. And moat importantly how you guys would draw a lot of eyes on these. I think planning for Denver is a better play to get this right, esp. When art print deadline is end of Sept.
Before commiting on development would love to see some card sketches and what lore (imo prop 16🤌🏽 great place to start) values and narrative of nouns examples as being CC0 and decentralized like art is very subjective
I’ve watched AceTCG develop for a number of years now. The cards are a perfect way to introduce someone to a public goods ethos
Have known and worked with Colton dating back to my Gitcoin days. He's someone who's very passionate and has been putting in the work for a very long time. Often much of that work being unseen.
Got a chance to see the cards at Edcon earlier this year, and definitely believe in the value prop of this.
tl;dr Let's bring Nouns mythology to life through physical trading cards at Devcon, creating a legendary fantasy IP that embodies Nounish creativity, optimism, and community.
Nouns already know this: Brands thrive on storytelling. We propose putting legendary Nounish mythology directly into the hands of passionate Devcon attendees using physical trading cards.
I founded AceTCG with a vision: show people how they can be heroes, solving real problems with today's magical technology. Each physical AceTCG card represents crypto lore, and this story would not be complete without a legendary Nouns card.
Highlights:
We bring people together in meaningful ways to play games and connect over our shared stories and values.
Ace is more than an IP; it's metaverse mythology. Like the mythology of our ancestors, I have always envisioned Ace becoming decentralized, using a Nouns model to curate and auction community-created cards. At present, we collaborate with stellar partners (like Nouns!), ensuring newcomers understand the vital roles these actors play in shaping our decentralized future.
Originally funded by Gitcoin as a public good, AceTCG has evolved into a vibrant community project celebrating the Ethereum ecosystem's rich mythology. Our inaugural Alpha Edition, created by just my brother and me, sold out at Devconnect and ETHDenver '23.
At AceTCG, we create magical moments for communities. Through epic art and playable, physical artifacts, Nouns will proliferate across the realm of metaverse mythology. This initiative drives:
What our community says:
This collaboration creates IP that can expand across all forms of engagement, from swag to memes and beyond.
Arx and AceTCG have teamed up to create NFC-enabled cards, literally bringing blockchain technology into players' hands. Beginning Q1 2025, this groundbreaking innovation will allow for:
we r gamers and #nerdz 🤓
Each 18-card booster will feature 1 legendary Nouns card and 2 additional Nouns cards. Nouns receives a 1-year license to use the created IP.
Sponsored cards are limited to this formative era of the Ace universe. Join us to make Nouns a cornerstone of metaverse mythology.
DEADLINE: Orders must be finalized by Sept 30 to ensure timely design and production for Devcon. If missed, this proposal will shift to an ETHDenver activation.
tl;dr Let's bring Nouns mythology to life through physical trading cards at Devcon, creating a legendary fantasy IP that embodies Nounish creativity, optimism, and community.
Nouns already know this: Brands thrive on storytelling. We propose putting legendary Nounish mythology directly into the hands of passionate Devcon attendees using physical trading cards.
I founded AceTCG with a vision: show people how they can be heroes, solving real problems with today's magical technology. Each physical AceTCG card represents crypto lore, and this story would not be complete without a legendary Nouns card.
Highlights:
We bring people together in meaningful ways to play games and connect over our shared stories and values.
Ace is more than an IP; it's metaverse mythology. Like the mythology of our ancestors, I have always envisioned Ace becoming decentralized, using a Nouns model to curate and auction community-created cards. At present, we collaborate with stellar partners (like Nouns!), ensuring newcomers understand the vital roles these actors play in shaping our decentralized future.
Originally funded by Gitcoin as a public good, AceTCG has evolved into a vibrant community project celebrating the Ethereum ecosystem's rich mythology. Our inaugural Alpha Edition, created by just my brother and me, sold out at Devconnect and ETHDenver '23.
At AceTCG, we create magical moments for communities. Through epic art and playable, physical artifacts, Nouns will proliferate across the realm of metaverse mythology. This initiative drives:
What our community says:
This collaboration creates IP that can expand across all forms of engagement, from swag to memes and beyond.
Arx and AceTCG have teamed up to create NFC-enabled cards, literally bringing blockchain technology into players' hands. Beginning Q1 2025, this groundbreaking innovation will allow for:
we r gamers and #nerdz 🤓
Each 18-card booster will feature 1 legendary Nouns card and 2 additional Nouns cards. Nouns receives a 1-year license to use the created IP.
Sponsored cards are limited to this formative era of the Ace universe. Join us to make Nouns a cornerstone of metaverse mythology.
DEADLINE: Orders must be finalized by Sept 30 to ensure timely design and production for Devcon. If missed, this proposal will shift to an ETHDenver activation.
