Nouncil has spoken.
We discuss all Nouns proposals every week in our Discord https://discord.gg/fdjJpMeV6K. The calls are public and all are welcome!
You can find a link to previous call recordings in our Discord "links" channel.
Nouncil has voted abstain on this proposal, with 17 votes for, 17 against, and 5 abstentions. What a result. Thanks for playing Nouns. See the comments of the Nouncil below:
FOR - 17 VOTES
jackwyldes | *"Why not? I think there has been some discussion about why we shouldn't hand out nouns because they aren't participating in governance... well in this case this person is full time participating.
maybe this changes that sentiment or maybe it doesn't but either way Bix has been here challenging others and I support this prop and others that reward nouns."*
sqx.pcc | *"there is a long list of people I think deserve a noun given that they are no longer held dear.
I prefer burning 90% of them however."*
.wideeyekarl. | "Prop edited. Swapped from low ID to Noun 761, even if its low ID, still deserving imo"
AGAINST - 17 VOTES
benbodhi | "I supported the prop for Drew to get a noun like this because it could set a precedent of attracting builders from the space that have valuable connections for nouns, along with his thoughtful reasons at the time. It's not entirely clear if that is the case atm.
I don't think it should happen often for this purpose and I think this would set the bar in a weird place where a lot of the community would feel entitled to a noun just for participating in voting, or voting as a contrarian.
Hosting the nouncil calls is not a factor I would take into consideration here, before the people who have held it down efficiently for the last few years preceeding. And noun 16!!! That's a super early ID that I don't think should be awarded so easily."
ryanmac.eth | "Participation trophies are a terrible idea"
ABSTAINS - 5 VOTES